Got Turkey leftovers from Thanksgiving? Make Turkey Pot Pie Soup!

Every Thanksgiving, I’m left with a ton of turkey. I usually make things like turkey pot pie and sandwiches out of it.

This year my mother in law called and asked if we really needed a turkey if only a few of us actually ate turkey.

I DO!

I almost shouted into the phone. I’m so adamant about getting a turkey because I love, love, love making broth with the carcass.

Turkey broth is one of my favorites, but I only get to make it once a year. And I’m not about to give that up. For a recipe check out my post on how to make bone broth.

Anyway, so I’m racking my brain trying to think of what the hell to make with the massive amount of leftover turkey meat I have.

I made paleo & grain free turkey tacos, I made turkey salad. So I head to the fridge and realize I’ve also got a ton of leftover celery, carrots, cream, onions, fresh sage, and fresh thyme.

A comforting Thanksgiving soup was born. It’s basically turkey pot pie soup. I didn’t have peas on hand but you can add those too!

Why this recipe for Turkey Pot Pie Soup works:

  • It’s filled with good protein and fiber-rich veggies, making it a healthy and nourishing meal.
  • You might already have all the necessary ingredients in your fridge!
  • The combination of bone broth and cream (or coconut cream) lends this turkey pot pie soup a wonderful creaminess without being too rich and heavy!

Variations on this recipe:

  • Make this a chicken pot pie soup by adding shredded leftover roasted chicken.
  • Feel free to use sweet potatoes instead of white potatoes.
  • If you cannot find fresh sage, add savory, marjoram, or rosemary instead.

 

Turkey Pot Pie Soup

Dani
This Turkey Pot Pie Soup is filled with good protein and fiber-rich veggies, making it a healthy and nourishing meal. You might already have all the necessary ingredients in your fridge! The combination of bone broth and cream lends this simple comforting soup a wonderful creaminess without being too rich and heavy!
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 10 mins
Cook Time 30 mins
Total Time 40 mins
Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Servings 2 servings

Ingredients
  

  • 3.5 cups bone broth
  • 1 cup heavy cream raw and grass-fed or use coconut cream
  • 3 tbsp butter
  • 2 carrots slices
  • 3 celery stalks sliced
  • 1 small peeled potato diced
  • 1 onion diced
  • 2 cups shredded turkey
  • 5 sage leaves chopped, about 1 tbsp
  • 1 tsp thyme
  • 1 tsp dried sage
  • optional: top with parsley
  • salt and pepper

Instructions
 

  • Melt the butter over medium heat in a big pot.
  • Add the onions, carrots, potato and celery.
  • Let cook until onions are soft.
  • Add the broth and cover the pot, letting it simmer for about twenty minutes, or until the carrots have softened.
  • Add the turkey and herbs.
  • Let them heat through.
  • Add the cream last.

Notes

  • Make this a chicken pot pie soup by adding shredded leftover roasted chicken.
  • Feel free to use sweet potatoes instead of white potatoes.
  • If you cannot find fresh sage, add savory, marjoram, or rosemary instead.
Keyword gluten-free pot pie soup, paleo pot pie soup, paleo turkey soup
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!
Turkey Pot Pie Soup - great for Thanksgiving leftovers! Easy lunch or dinner recipe! Paleo and gluten-free! #paleo, #souprecipes
This Turkey Pot Pie Soup is filled with good protein and fiber-rich veggies, making it a healthy and nourishing meal. You might already have all the necessary ingredients in your fridge! The combination of bone broth and cream lends this simple comforting soup a wonderful creaminess without being too rich and heavy! #paleo #potpie #turkeyrecipes #cleaneating #paleorecipes

49 Comments

  1. My very very favorite way to make yummy soup with leftover turkey is to add some of the gravy to the bone broth with all the other goodies. Give it a try next time.

    This looks delicious!

  2. Super easy to put together and quick BUT I substituted coconut cream for the heavy cream and YIKES….NOT GOOD! Definitely don’t use coconut cream for a substitute.

      • Hi, I am about to try this soup and usually sub coconut cream/milk for dairy. Is the issue consistency or flavor with the coconut cream?

    • We tried it with a can of coconut milk and really liked it! Maybe the cream is too sweet!

    • I use coconut cream regularly in this recipe, and it turns out amazing so I’m not sure what your issue was.

  3. I usually have a difficult time getting my husband to try new things. I made this soup after making up a batch of turkey stock, and disappeared to do projects for a couple of days. My husband told me he has eaten the soup 3 times! I was lucky to get even a bowl! It was yummy! Thank you

      • 5 stars
        Very easy to prepare. I had cooked a turkey beast (bone in) and refrigerated it overnight. Removed the fat and used the broth for the soup. Great way to use leftover turkey. Added a bag of frozen peas instead of the potatoes. Delicious!

    • Cream, either coconut or milk-based does not freeze well. Make the soup with all of the ingredients except the cream, freeze and then when you thaw it to use, remember to add the cream in.

  4. Has anyone used a substitute for the butter? I can’t have any dairy (so also no ghee).

    • dani Reply

      Whichever oil you prefer for cooking. Maybe olive oil as coconut would add too much unwanted flavor to the soup.

    • dani Reply

      I would cook the quinoa separately, and add it to your bowl, then spoon the soup over. Sounds good!

  5. I’m wondering how this is paleo? As the true paleo diet does not allow potatoes nor dairy?

    • dani Reply

      You’re right, it’s not paleo. But it is made-from-scratch and delicious!

      • Carrie Chance Reply

        you should probably change your graphic then since it’s not actually paleo. It’s misleading

  6. My family loves soup but my kids never like the same ones. This is a soup that my WHOLE family LOVES! I’ve made it 5 times in the last month, and we’re not sick of it. I’ve taken it to parties and everyone asks for the recipe. Thank you for this delicious recipe!

    • dani Reply

      Thanks! I love when we find a meal everyone will eat without complaints.

  7. Pingback: 100 Best Paleo Diet Recipes We Love | Meraki Lane

  8. Pingback: Turkey Pot Pie Soup - Symptom Information

  9. I Made this tonight( yesterday was ??Canadian Thanksgiving) it was so yummy, I did add some peas! I will definately make again, love the idea that someone posted about using a rotisserie chicken, may try that if Turkey isn’t convenient! ?? Thanks for sharing this, made it pretty much almost all Keto, except for using about half of a small potato!

  10. Pingback: Meal Plan for Nov. 11 – 17 – Grocery Sales Weekly

  11. Pingback: Meal Plan for Nov. 18-24 – Grocery Sales Weekly

  12. Found this recipe last year and made it a lot.Have my bone broth cooking now to making this on Sunday. Can’t wait! Absolutely love it! My mouth is now watering. Lol

  13. LOOOOVED this! And so did my husband! Used 1 can of coconut milk (not cream) and added quinoa. Fantastic flavor and dairy free!

  14. Pingback: 30+ Ideas for Leftover Turkey - Lydia's Flexitarian Kitchen

  15. Can you substitute milk or 1/2 and 1/2 in place of heavy cream to make it lighter?

  16. Pingback: Paleo Meal Plan Monday - Week of January 1st | Midwest Modern Momma

  17. Pingback: 30+ Recovery Soups to Heal Your Gut (Nourishing, Paleo) | The Hearty Soul

  18. Pingback: 30+ Recovery Soups to Heal Your Gut (Nourishing, Paleo) - MagazinAisle

  19. Pingback: Gut-health, Paleo diet, and Farmer’s Markets – chelsea osicka

  20. Pingback: 15 Paleo Diet Lunch Recipes: Lunch can be healthy and yummy – Top Reveal

  21. Pingback: Anti-Inflammatory Soup Recipes That Fight Inflammation and Cleanse the Gut | Longevity Box

  22. Pingback: 101 Gluten-free Dairy-free Crockpot Recipes - Rachael Roehmholdt

  23. I always Meal prep 1 meal a week and decided to go for this! I loved It! I used The coconut cream too and it was delish!

    Thank you for sharing!

  24. Pingback: Recipe Roundup- December  – Wholistically Holly

  25. Pingback: Turkey Pot Pie Soup | All Food Board

  26. Pingback: 29 Easy Leftover Meals That Make the Most of Your Food

  27. Pingback: Grain-Free Weekly Meal Plan 2/1 - 2/6 - Real Life Outlaws

  28. Pingback: Menu Plan Monday ~ October 14/19 Weekly Dinner Inspiration

Write A Comment

Recipe Rating





This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.